cutting.
Therefore, for most versions of the puzzle, treating the tears as holes is reasonable.
What If a Tear Connects to the Edge?
Here’s another complication.
Suppose you cut a circular hole in a shirt.
That’s clearly an enclosed opening.
Now imagine extending the cut until it reaches the edge of the fabric.
Is it still a hole?
In everyday language, you might call it a tear.
From a topological perspective, the structure has changed.
This demonstrates that counting “holes” depends partly on how the openings are shaped and connected.